HEADLINES

In defense of selecting Peyton Manning over John Elway

Jul 12, 2019, 9:11 AM | Updated: Jul 15, 2019, 11:20 am

OK, hear me out. I know most of you won’t read past the headline, but try to have an open mind.

Choosing Peyton Manning over John Elway as the greatest Denver Broncos player in the franchise’s 60 years of existence isn’t the craziest notion of all-time.

In fact, it’s not indefensible. And defend it, I will try here.

Trust me, it’s a tough pill to swallow for me, who grew up idolizing No. 7 so much that the number shows up in nearly every social media handle I have. And, certainly by the outpouring of comments Thursday, it clear it wasn’t an easy pill for most of Broncos Country to swallow either.

But, no. I didn’t draw the short straw here to defend my colleague James Merilatt. Though, if I did so, I would do so at full volume, as I would with any of my co-workers who have brilliant, sometimes eccentric, sports minds.

Yes, I come to you — under the full understanding that this will at no point make me popular among our audience — in defense of Manning over Elway in the 104.3 The Fan “Sixty Since 60” list.

First off, a list like this is purely subjective. James is one opinion, and whether you disagree with it is not only your right but your obligation.

That’s not the defense, however.

Statistically, you can make the case that Manning, during his four-year run in the Mile High City, has as much or more impact on the franchise as Elway — at least on the field.

Everyone, please turn your hymnals to Pro Football Reference, page “Approximate Value.”

Sure, the “Approximate Value” metric employed by the holy grail of sports statistic websites is a metric that is ever changing. In fact, in the site’s explanation of the methodology it employs to come up with the AV score — a methodology I won’t go into detail here because, well, I’m not sure if I understand it myself — says that “Approximate Value” should be considered an “evolving document” of algorithms.

“Approximate Value,” however, is a metric that attempts to quantify a player’s value to a team over a certain period of time and is an objective way to compare Elway and Manning (and for that matter all pro football players since 1950).

Obviously, Elway leads the franchise in career AV due to his elite play over an extended period of time, coming in with a score of 203. Manning falls in line at No. 53, with a score of 52 during his time in Denver.

But, if you break down the AV score over the number of games played, Manning, in fact, has a higher average AV (.897 per game) than Elway (.868).

Over a 16-game season, that roughly equates to an AV of .464, which comes out to a difference of 7.424 over the span of a 16-year career.

While not a large difference, it’s not insignificant.

And I guess that’s the point.

Yes, a wide range of factors, both objective and subjective, go into lists like this. And by no means is James’ “Sixty Since 60” perfect. But to call putting Manning No. 1 over Elway crazy is, in itself, ludicrous.

 

Headlines

PHOENIX, ARIZONA - MARCH 28: Kris Bryant #23 of the Colorado Rockies makes a catch for an out again...

Jake Shapiro

Rockies get destroyed in embarrassing fashion on Opening Day

Baseball is a long season but this year in Denver it's going to be extra long as evidenced by the Colorado Rockies stinker on Opening Day

8 hours ago

DU hockey...

Will Petersen

DU hockey moving on in NCAA Tournament after dramatic 2OT win

DU hockey forward Tristan Broz played hero, finding the back of the net on a slick wrist-shot with 7:33 to go in the second overtime session

12 hours ago

Drake Maye Broncos QB...

Andrew Mason

Broncos have George Paton, QB coach at Drake Maye Pro Day

QB prospect Drake Maye had his Pro Day workout on March 28, and Broncos GM George Paton was among those on hand.

15 hours ago

Bud Black...

Will Petersen

Bud Black says Rockies players aware no one gives them a chance

"They don't say much publicly, but internally the guys are not liking what they're hearing," Bud Black said on 104.3 The Fan on Thursday

17 hours ago

Elehuris Montero high fives Colorado Rockies teammate Brendan Rodgers...

Jake Shapiro and Andrew Mason

Rockies reveal Opening Day roster for 2024 season

The Colorado Rockies are ready for 2024 Opening Day, revealing their roster ahead of Thursday's season opener in Phoenix.

18 hours ago

Joe Sakic Stanley Cup documentary...

Will Petersen

The trailer for the new Joe Sakic documentary looks fascinating

The documentary "Saving Sakic" is about how the Avs found the cash to keep Joe after the Rangers signed him to a huge offer sheet

18 hours ago

In defense of selecting Peyton Manning over John Elway